The Responsive, Accomplished Legal Allies
You Want In Your Corner

  1. Home
  2.  • 
  3. Criminal Defense
  4.  • Problems inherent in police lineups

Problems inherent in police lineups

On Behalf of | Mar 21, 2023 | Criminal Defense, Illegal Search And Seizure |

Police lineups have long been used to identify suspects in Iowa criminal investigations. However, in recent years, there has been growing concern over the reliability of eyewitness identification and the potential for police lineups to result in wrongful convictions.

Unintentional cues from law enforcement

Studies have shown that unintentional cues from law enforcement officers can influence witnesses during the identification process. For example, an officer may unintentionally indicate to the witness which lineup member they believe is the suspect through verbal or nonverbal cues, such as nodding or eye contact. This can cause the witness to select the person the officer believes is the suspect, rather than rely on their own memory.

Witness expectations and memory biases

Witnesses may also have expectations about what the suspect looks like, based on descriptions provided by law enforcement or the media. This can lead to memory biases and influence the witness’s identification. Additionally, witnesses may be more likely to identify someone who looks similar to their expectations, even if they are not the actual suspect.

Limited lineup options

In some cases, police lineups may be limited to a small number of individuals, making it more likely for the witness to select someone simply because they stand out from the others. This can be particularly problematic if authorities do not include the actual suspect in the lineup, leading to a wrongful identification and potentially a wrongful conviction.

Cross-racial identification

Research has shown that people are often better at recognizing faces of their own race, and that cross-racial identification can be more difficult and prone to error. This can be problematic in cases where a witness is asked to identify a suspect of a different race, leading to potential misidentifications.

Lack of standardization

Police lineups are not standardized across jurisdictions, which can lead to inconsistencies and errors in the criminal defense process. Some jurisdictions may use live lineups, where the witness views the individuals in person, while others may use photo lineups. Additionally, the procedures used to administer the lineup may vary, often leading to confusion and potential errors.

Improving police lineup effectiveness

While police lineups have been a valuable tool in identifying suspects in criminal investigations, there are concerns over their reliability and potential for wrongful convictions. Some experts argue that alternative methods, such as using technology to create more standardized lineups, should be discussed.

More emphasis should go toward training law enforcement officers on conducting lineups to minimize the potential for unintentional cues and other biases. Ultimately, the goal should be to improve the accuracy and reliability of eyewitness identification, while also ensuring that the rights of suspects are protected.



FindLaw Network